- About
About USC Gould
USC Gould is a top-ranked law school with a 120-year history and reputation for academic excellence. We are located on the beautiful 228-acre USC University Park Campus, just south of downtown Los Angeles.
- Academics
Academics
Learn about our interdisciplinary curriculum, experiential learning opportunities and specialized areas.
Student Quick Links:
- Admissions
Admissions
USC Gould helps prepare you for a stellar legal career. You can pursue a JD degree, one of our numerous graduate and international offerings, or an online degree or certificate.
- Students
Students
Participate in an unparalleled learning experience with diversity of people and thought. Get involved in the law school community and participate in activities that enhance your studies.
Student Quick Links:
- Careers
Careers
We work closely with students, graduates and employers to support successful career goals and outcomes. Our overall placement rate is consistently strong, with 94 percent of our JD class employed within 10 months after graduation.
- Faculty
Faculty
Our faculty is distinguished for its scholarship, as well as for its commitment to teaching. Our 12:1 student-to-faculty ratio creates an intimate and collegial learning environment.
- Alumni and Giving
- Admissions

Method or Madness?
USC Gould School of Law
- ABOUT USC GOULD
- A MESSAGE FROM THE DEAN
- + HISTORY OF USC GOULD
- LAW, RACE AND EQUITY
- + NEWS
- + EVENTS
- BOARD OF COUNCILORS
- CONSUMER INFORMATION (ABA REQUIRED DISCLOSURES)
- VISIT US
- SOCIAL MEDIA
- + CONTACT US
Thursday, February 3, 2011
Justice Anthony Kennedy presides over “The Trial of Hamlet”
by Darren Schenck
photos ©Ryan Miller/Capture Imaging
On Monday night, literary history’s most famous melancholic was subject to a modern American trial. Having suffered the slings and arrows of murderous family and disloyal friends, not to mention a poisoning from which he miraculously recovered, Hamlet stoically endured the scrutiny of attorneys and psychiatrists, judge and jury. Together they parsed Hamlet’s soliloquies, speeches and actions to determine whether the young prince was criminally responsible for the murder of Polonius.
![]() |
Justice Anthony Kennedy instructs the jury |
Put more colloquially: was Hamlet insane when he stabbed at the arras?
Presented by the Shakespeare Center of Los Angeles, and adjudicated by Supreme Court Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, “The Trial of Hamlet” featured top lawyers, expert witnesses and a jury whose early deliberations were broadcast to the audience. The one-time mock trial event was held in USC’s Bovard Auditorium Jan. 31.
After the bailiff, attired in period costume, called the court to order, Justice Kennedy outlined the proceedings for the benefit of jury and audience.
“The sole purpose of this trial is to determine, at the time Polonius was killed, was Hamlet criminally responsible?” Justice Kennedy said. He offered that Shakespeare’s account of events could be used during the trial.
![]() |
Richard Hirsch argues that Hamlet is not |
“After 400 years, we are finally getting our day in court,” crowed Blair Berk, a named partner in the firm of Tarlow & Berk, for the defense. “Sane, or not sane, that is the question.”
After reviewing the facts of the case and declaring Hamlet not criminally responsible, Berk called for the defense Dr. Saul J. Faerstein, clinical professor of psychiatry at UCLA.
Drawing lavishly and cleverly on the text of “Hamlet,” Faerstein recalled “the inky blackness” of the prince’s melancholia as an indication of a major depressive episode, and he leaned heavily on the “command hallucination” Hamlet experienced in the form of his slain father’s ghost, who exhorts his son to revenge.
Both the defense and prosecution granted that ghost sightings were more common several hundred years ago and therefore not a sufficient indication of madness.
Danette Myers, past president of the L.A. Bar Association and a 24-year veteran of the L.A. District Attorney’s office, detailed the rationality of Hamlet’s actions leading up to Polonius’s death, particularly the prince’s decision not to murder his uncle, the king, when Hamlet found him praying.
“These are the words of a very thoughtful individual,” she said, adding that Hamlet feigns insanity throughout the play.
“Acting crazy doesn’t make you crazy,” she said.
![]() |
The ever-suffering Hamlet, played by Graham Hamilton |
Dr. Ronald Markman, holder of a law degree and a psychiatrist on staff at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center and the UCLA School of Medicine, was called for the prosecution.
Much of the testimony and cross-examination parsed the definition of insanity as described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders – referred to throughout the evening as the “Danish Statistical Manual.” The attorneys for both sides, and especially the psychiatrists, displayed a formidable recall of the play, heavily quoting from it to buttress their arguments.
Meanwhile, the title character of what is arguably the greatest play ever written, the man whose soliloquies include some of the most famous lines in all of literature, remained silent throughout the proceedings. Played by Graham Hamilton, Hamlet was not only the sole participant dressed in period costume, but also the only character. At the outset, his placid expression and noble carriage comprised the 800-pound gorilla in the room: when would Hamlet, whose fate was in the balance, join the proceedings?
But as the second half of the trial unfolded, the figure of Hamlet became more diminutive, almost unnoticeable. Although the Dane forever will occupy his role as one of the most compelling characters in all literature, this was a night for lawyers.
And the verdict? Ten jurors found Hamlet criminally responsible, or sane, with two jurors finding him not criminally responsible. Justice Kennedy thanked the jurors, lawyers and witnesses before remanding Hamlet to the further conjecture of actors, scholars, readers, lawyers and psychiatrists for generations to come.
![]() |
From left: Prosecutor Danette Myers, Dr. Ronald Markman, attorney Nathan Hochman, Justice Kennedy, Dr. Saul Faerstein, attorney Richard Hirsch, attorney Blair Berk |
Read More
- Next Article: Interview Dos and Don'ts
- Previous Article: Supreme Court Justice Lectures on Constitutional Law
RECENT NEWS

Elyn Saks honored for efforts to lessen stigma of mental illness
March 20, 2023
Prof. Saks earns 2023 President’s Award from Schizophrenia International Research Society

Mentorship, overcoming obstacles among inspiring lessons shared at 2023 Ruth Lavine Women in Law Symposium
March 14, 2023
The event was hosted by the Women’s Law Association

Research by Dorothy Lund instrumental in influential corporate sexual harassment court decision
March 8, 2023
Delaware Chancery Court cites paper in ruling that shareholders can sue fiduciaries in McDonald’s case